4 Criminally Underrated Drams

I don’t know if it’s just me, but some things in life don’t receive anywhere near the amount of love and positive feedback that they should. Peter Crouch for example, was hugely underrated in my humble opinion, particularly in a Liverpool shirt (a goal roughly every 3 games is not to be sniffed at you know). A little ketchup with fish and chips is another great example.

Okay, now that you’re ready for a debate, let’s talk whisky. While there are plenty of enormously popular drams out there that have received multiple awards and a great deal of positive feedback in the process, there are also a number of hidden gems that are, in my opinion, hugely underrated.

As you have probably deduced, for today’s blog, I’m going to be exploring a few of the drams out there that have slipped through the cracks and flown under the radar. From Kentucky bourbons to smoky Islay expressions, here are 4 drams which are criminally underrated.

Elements of Islay – Sherry Cask

The first dram I have for you today comes from Elements of Islay and it’s a belter. If you enjoy a sherry monster with plenty of spicy peat smoke, all with lashings of burn on the way down, this is the perfect whisky for you.

Elements of Islay is an independent bottling range created by the fantastic Elixir Distillers in 2008. The range is known for its scientific styled labels, inspired by the periodic tables, which is just as well as they love to experiment with the drams they put out.

This blended malt is made from a selection of malts from the north and south of Islay so there’s a great contrast of styles here. It was matured in a mixture of refill and first-fill sherry butts and hogsheads and is bottled at a fiery 54.5% ABV. It offers up plenty of sweet, fruity, spicy, and nutty sherry notes with a hint of citrus, spicy peat smoke, and subtle maritime notes. For less than sixty quid a bottle, you can’t go wrong.

Photo Credit: The Whisky Exchange

Tobermory 12 Year Old

For my next underrated dram, I’ve a fantastic 12-year-old drop from Tobermory.

The Tobermory Distillery was founded on the Isle of Mull, way back in 1798. Having been founded more than two centuries ago, this artisan distillery has opened and closed several times over the centuries. Thankfully, it is currently fully operational and putting out amazing drams as a result.

This 12-year-old single malt was originally released in 2019, in celebration of the distillery being reawakened following a two year hiatus. It was a moment worthy of a celebration, and what better way to celebrate than with an amazing single malt?

Having matured for twelve years in American oak casks, it was bottled at a smooth 46.3% ABV and features subtle fruity, honey, slightly citrusy notes with hints of creamy malt, honey, and golden caramel.

Having won gold and silver awards in 2022 and 2019 respectively, it can be yours for less than £40. It’s not often you can enjoy an award-winning dram for less than £40 (shameless plug alert, you can with a number of our GreatDrams expressions) but thanks to Tobermory, you can here.

Photo Credit: Tobermory

Woodford Reserve Double Oaked

As the warmer summer months are now within sight, it’s time to talk bourbon.

Woodford Reserve is one of the most recognisable bourbons on the market today. For a mid-range bourbon, it’s perfectly fine. It’s not my fav of all time, but I am partial to a glass now and then. This double oaked variety, however, really is criminally underrated here in the UK, and I want to change that.

The whiskey starts out as regular Woodford Reserve Kentucky straight bourbon, before enjoying a second maturation period in heavily toasted and lightly charred oak barrels (hence the name). This additional maturation period really helps to impart some amazingly sweet, vanilla, caramel, and sweet oaken notes into the whiskey.

The end result is a sweeter, more complex and refined take on Woodford Reserve, with extra layers of caramel, charred oak, vanilla, honey, black cherries, and winter baking spices. Despite bourbon often being associated with warmer summer weather as it often works well over ice, this would be a fantastic dram to enjoy around Christmas.

While prices vary, typically you can expect to spend around £55 for a bottle, which I think is more than reasonable. If you’re thinking of trying standard Woodford Reserve, my advice would be to spend a little more and grab the Double Oaked variety instead. Miles better.

Photo Credit: The Whisky Exchange

Wire Works Coastal Smoke

Finally, we’re travelling back to the Derbyshire Dales to look at another expression from the White Peak’s Wire Works Distillery – Coastal Smoke.

I’ve covered Wire Works a few times in the past, and for good reason. Not only are they located in a gorgeous setting in the Peak District National Park, but they’re also doing wonders for English whisky, and are really helping it to stand out and find its own identity, rather than living in its northern neighbour’s shadow.

Despite being about as far from the coast as you can possibly be, Wire Works have done a great job of bringing the Islay coastline to mainland Derbyshire through a unique dual maturation process. To begin with, the whisky was matured in first-fill bourbon barrels sourced from Heaven Hill. The coastal influence, however, comes next. For its second maturation period, the whisky is finished in casks which were once home to peated whisky from Islay. The end result is a dram with fruity and tropical notes, combined with briny, salty, peaty, and smoky flavours. The sweet and fruity influences work amazingly well with the salty and smoky notes and help tie everything together fantastically well. At 50% ABV it also has plenty of burn, just like you’d expect with an Islay expression.

This is the most expensive dram on my list today, averaging around £65 – £70 but for me personally, it’s worth every penny.

Photo Credit: Master of Malt

If you’d like to learn more about your favourite whiskies, or simply treat yourself to a dram or two in the process, head on over to GreatDrams.com and take a look at the diverse selection of unique whiskies we currently have in stock.

With an impressive selection of limited-edition, rare, and award-winning whisky, as well as heaps of whisky info on our blog, it’s the perfect spot for any whisky lovers out there.  

Tags: Underrated Drams
Picture of Greg

Greg

My name is Greg, and I’m a brand strategy consultant, writer, speaker, host and judge specialising in premium spirits. My mission is to experience, share and inspire with everything great about whisky, whiskey, gin, beer and fine dining through my writing, my brand building and my whisky tastings.

You might be interested in

More from the blog

Leave a comment

Login / register